Thriving amid giants: Balancing e-commerce marketplaces with your own store


Discover strategies for e-commerce success, balancing your presence on marketplaces like Amazon, eBay, and Etsy, with your own online store.

Navigating the e-commerce landscape often involves juggling your presence across multiple platforms. From managing your own online store to listing on vast marketplaces like Amazon, eBay, and Etsy, success hinges on your ability to balance and optimise each channel.

While managing multi-channel retail can seem daunting, the rewards are significant. You gain access to a broader audience, enjoy increased visibility, and have multiple touchpoints with your customers. Here, we delve into key strategies including differentiation, customer engagement, and effective marketing, to help you achieve a balanced and prosperous multi-channel strategy.

Embracing differentiation: Stand out on marketplaces and your own store

Differentiation is the key to gaining visibility and capturing customer interest across all your sales channels. Your unique selling proposition (USP) can stem from your product, pricing, quality, or customer service. It's essential to communicate this effectively on both your online store and marketplace listings.

For instance, while your online store can tell a more comprehensive brand story and provide a curated shopping experience, your marketplace listings can reach a vast audience and offer convenience. Harness the strengths of each platform to effectively convey your USP and attract customers.

Consider the case of Gymshark, a UK-based fitness apparel brand. They have successfully carved out a niche in the crowded fitness industry by focusing on fitness enthusiasts and offering high-quality, aesthetically pleasing workout clothes. Additionally, they prioritise excellent customer service, offering quick response times and an easy return policy.

Winning the SEO battle: Optimise for each platform

SEO is not a one-size-fits-all approach when it comes to multi-channel e-commerce. Each platform, including your own website, Amazon, eBay, and Etsy, has its own search algorithms. To improve visibility across the board, you need to tailor your SEO strategy to each platform.

Use the analytic tools of each platform to understand what keywords customers are using, then incorporate these into your product titles, descriptions, and tags. At the same time, make sure your own website is SEO-optimised to draw organic traffic from search engines.

For instance, when selling on Amazon, focus on Amazon's A9 algorithm. Include relevant keywords in your product title, bullet points, and backend keywords. For your own website, make sure meta descriptions, title tags, and alt image texts are SEO-optimised.

Engaging customers: Foster relationships across all channels

Customer engagement in multi-channel e-commerce involves creating a consistent brand experience across all touchpoints. Whether customers visit your standalone website, your Amazon storefront, or your Etsy shop, they should receive the same level of service and interaction.

Invest in CRM tools to manage customer interactions and maintain communication through automated emails, social media updates, and personalised marketing. This helps foster customer loyalty and encourage repeat purchases across all channels.

Consider, a UK-based online retailer that excels in customer service. They have implemented strategies like speedy delivery, installation services, and excellent post-sale customer support across all their platforms.

Leverage the power of reviews and ratings

Reviews and ratings are crucial both for your own e-commerce store and marketplace listings. They provide social proof, build buyer trust, and can significantly impact your search rankings on platforms like Amazon and eBay.

Encourage satisfied customers to leave reviews regardless of the platform they used for purchase. Address any negative reviews politely and professionally. Show potential customers your commitment to resolving issues, which can enhance your brand's reputation across all channels.

Consider offering incentives like discounts or free samples for customers who leave a review on your products. Make sure to reply to these reviews, both positive and negative, to show your engagement with customers.

Effective marketing: Harness the power of each platform

Take advantage of the marketing tools provided by each platform. These can include sponsored product listings on Amazon, featured listings on Etsy, and advanced analytics on your own website. Meanwhile, external traffic can be directed to your most suitable platform through social media advertising, email marketing, or SEO.

Maintaining consistent branding across your multi-channel marketing efforts can enhance brand recognition and increase the effectiveness of your campaigns.

Before being bought by Next for £3.4m in November 2022,, a UK-based furniture retailer, was known for its effective multi-platform marketing. They used social media advertising to drive traffic to their own website and their Amazon listings, and they used retargeting ads to engage potential customers who showed an interest in their products.

Conclusion: Rising above the competition in a multi-channel world

Thriving in the world of multi-channel e-commerce is about balance and synergy. Leveraging the strengths of each platform, from your own online store to major marketplaces, allows you to reach a wider audience and create multiple touchpoints with your customers.

As you juggle these different platforms, remember the wise words of Jeff Bezos, "We see our customers as invited guests to a party, and we are the hosts. It's our job every day to make every important aspect of the customer experience a little bit better."

With a customer-centric approach and a well-executed multi-channel strategy, you can indeed host a memorable party in the e-commerce world, leaving a lasting impression on your guests and rising above the competition.

Visit our e-commerce page to explore how we can support your growth.

Sign up for our latest insights